It is all too common in the context of estate litigation for a party to obtain valuations of a property that accords with their own interests. This is not to say that such valuations cannot be used, but this type of evidence warrants caution given the subjectivity involved.
For example, a high valuation may suit an executor who is seeking to maintain the status quo, whereas a low valuation could assist a claimant in securing a deal at mediation. This is not an uncommon situation, and the true value of the property may rest somewhere in between.
This article considers the circumstances in which valuations should be sought, what type of valuation should be sought and the consequences for failing to do so.
When does the need for expert evidence arise?
In every estate dispute, the parties (and the court) will benefit from having a clear understanding of the assets that make up the estate. Any party can call upon expert evidence (including valuation evidence) in the course of estate proceedings. Often times, the duty to identify the estate will rest upon the executor(s). Under the Supreme Court Practice Direction 14 of 2023, the court gives the following sample directions order:
“on or before x date” the respondent is to file and serve an affidavit (personal representative’s initial affidavit) containing or exhibiting… an estimate, formed from the evidence available to the respondent, of the assets, liabilities and value of the estate of the deceased as at the date of death and the date of the affidavit.”
At other times, a beneficiary may wish to file their own evidence of the value of a particular asset. This is particularly common in the context of family provision applications, where a claimant may have identified a particular property (e.g the family home) which they are seeking by way of adequate provision. In these circumstances, the claimant will generally want the valuation to come in at a lower figure.
Is a “desktop” appraisal sufficient for real estate?
The suitability of a desktop appraisal as evidence will depend on a number of factors:
- The point in the proceedings;
- whether it will be relied upon at trial; and
- the role of the party who is seeking to rely on the evidence.
At an early stage in the proceedings (for example, the filing of the personal representative’s initial affidavit), a desktop appraisal may well suffice as a preliminary indication of the value of a particular asset. As an executor, it is prudent to keep expenses commensurate with the size of the estate and the issues in dispute.
This position differs at trial. Valuation evidence generally falls under the category of expert evidence – meaning that the expert’s opinion will be admissible as evidence in a trial. Such evidence is subject to the requirements set out in Chapter 11, Part 5 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (1999) QLD, including that:
- The expert has specialized knowledge;
- The subject matter falls within their area of expertise; and
- The expert maintains a duty to assist the court and act impartially.
A case study: costs awarded against executors who failed to obtain sufficient valuations
The case of Wagner v Wagner (No 2) [2026] QSC 185 (Wagner no.2) is an example of the cost consequences that can follow a failure to obtain sufficient valuations. Wagner no.2 was an application for costs brought by the applicants, after partially succeeding in their applications for further provision from the Estate in the proceedings Wagner v Wagner [2026] QSC 139 (Wagner no.1).
Relevant to the costs application, there had been substantial disputes about valuations in the matter. Her Honour Treston J said in Wagner no.2:
“[7] there was a dispute about the valuation evidence which the respondents had obtained. Despite a number of complaints and requests, the applicants ultimately had to bring an application for orders pertaining to those valuations. In Wagner no.1, I ordered the respondent executors obtain new valuations which would properly evaluate land and shares held by the estate.”
The Law
The applicable provision was rule 700A of the UCPR, which offers guidance in relations to costs arising under a will or trust:
“The court may, in determining an order for costs, take into account matters including:
(a) the value of the property the subject of the proceeding;
(b) whether costs have been increased because of any one or more of the following:
(i) non-compliance with the rules;
(ii) non-compliance with a practice direction;
(iii) the litigation of unmeritorious issues;
(iv) failure to make, promptly or at all, appropriate concessions or admissions; and
(v) giving unwarranted attention to minor or peripheral issues.”
Analysis
Her Honour Treston J awarded indemnity costs from the estate. In giving her reasons, she relied on seven separate grounds. Four of these grounds related to the executors’ failure to provide sufficient valuation evidence throughout the course of the matter:
[13] Second, it must have been obvious to all the parties that a reliable and accurate assessment of the estate was necessary so that the claims for provision out of the estate could be properly considered.
[14] Third, the history of the matter reflects that an order had been made for a valuation of shares by RSM Australia. As I concluded in Wagner at [54] – [56], the “limited scope valuation” obtained by the respondents was not one which properly accorded with that order of 11 September 2025.
[15] Fourth, the Herron Todd White valuations, which were obtained in respect of land held by the estate, were desktop valuations in circumstances where there was no evidence before me explaining why such limited valuations had been sought: Wagner, [34]. The valuer’s own reports identified the risks associated with such a valuation, including the risk of inaccuracy of information and the inability to verify the accuracy of the information which informed the valuation:
[16] Fifth, the applicants took issue with both the share valuation and the land valuations on a number of occasions prior to the filing of the application (11 December 2025, 2 February 2026, 26 February 2026 and 20 March 2026), and despite those requests, were ultimately forced to proceed with this application.
Conclusion
Valuations are generally a useful tool for parties in estate litigation to ventilate issues in dispute and resolve matters quickly. Timely and sufficiently detailed valuations (while costly) become particularly relevant in complex estates which comprise of a web of entities owned or controlled by the deceased at the time of their death. Wagner no.2 is an example of such an estate, and the consequences that can follow if an executor fails to act upon reasonable requests for valuation evidence.
If you are an executor seeking advise on how to comply with your duties, or a claimant considering challenging an estate, contact Rostron Carlyle Lawyers or Michael Sing today to discuss your options.
Disclaimer: The information contained in this blog post is provided for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading or accessing this content does not create a solicitor-client relationship between you and Rostron Carlyle Lawyers. Because valuation requirements and cost consequences in estate litigation depend on the specific facts and assets of each matter, you should not rely on this article as a substitute for tailored legal advice. Please contact Rostron Carlyle Lawyers directly to discuss your individual situation before taking any action.