Being a stepchild does not automatically prevent you from making a claim against your step-parent’s estate. Queensland law recognises stepchildren as eligible applicants for further provision from a deceased person’s estate, and there are circumstances in which a claim may be justified even where the step-parent has expressly excluded you from their Will.
Being left out of a Will can be a stressful event if the expectation is to be included. The difficulties are compounded when the surviving parent does not necessarily enjoy the same relationship with the children of the deceased parent. It is not uncommon for a surviving spouse to leave the entire estate to their biological children upon their passing, to the exclusion of the other’s children.
How can you challenge a will if you are left out?
In Queensland, an eligible person may challenge a Will by making a family provision application under section 41 of the Succession Act 1981 (Qld) (“the Act”).
Section 41 allows the Court to order further provision from a deceased person’s estate where adequate provision has not been made for the proper maintenance and support of an eligible person. The eligible categories include:
- a spouse (de-facto or legal);
- a child; or
- a dependant of the deceased.
For stepchildren, an important preliminary question is whether they fall within the statutory definition of a child under the Act.
Eligibility as a stepchild
In short, Queensland law recognises stepchildren as eligible claimants in the same way as biological children for the purposes of family provision claims.
Section 40 of the Succession Act 1981 defines a child to include a child, stepchild or adopted child of the deceased. Accordingly, a stepchild does not need to establish that they were financially dependent on the deceased to qualify as an eligible applicant in their capacity as a child.
The question of who is a stepchild under the section 40A of the Act turns to the relationship between the biological parent and step parent. Broadly, the person must be the child of a spouse of the deceased, and the relationship of stepchild and step-parent must not have ended in any of the below ways:
- Divorce of the parents;
- termination of the civil partnership; or
- ending of the De-facto relationship.
Importantly, the relationship does not automatically end when:
- The biological parent dies. Provided the marriage, civil partnership or de facto relationship between the biological parent and step-parent subsisted at the time of the biological parent’s death, the relationship can continue for the purposes of a subsequent family provision claim.
- The stepparent remarried or entered a de-facto relationship after the passing of the biological parent, so long as the stepparent and biological parent were in a relationship at the time of death.
Is my claim weaker than the claim of a biological child?
Not necessarily. Once a person establishes that they are an eligible applicant, there is no automatic presumption that a stepchild’s claim is inferior to that of a biological child.
The Court will consider the particular circumstances of the relationship between the applicant and the deceased. This includes the nature, strength and duration of the relationship, whether the step-parent assumed a parental role, the extent of any financial or emotional support, and the circumstances in which the applicant was excluded from the Will.
It is important to understand that eligibility does not guarantee an entitlement to an inheritance. The applicant must still establish that adequate provision has not been made for their proper maintenance and support. The Court must then determine what provision, if any, should be ordered having regard to all relevant circumstances.
My biological parent contributed everything to the estate, and now I am left out
Consider the following common example of a dispute that can arise in a blended family:
- Your father enters into a relationship with your stepmother, bringing substantial assets into the relationship, including the family home.
- Your stepmother also has children from a previous relationship.
- Your father and stepmother build a life together over several decades.
- Your father dies first, leaving his estate to your stepmother, or his assets otherwise pass to her through joint ownership and survivorship.
- Your stepmother subsequently dies, leaving her entire estate to her biological children and making no provision for you or your siblings
Regrettably, these circumstances are not uncommon in estate litigation. The important question is whether the “moral obligation” your biological parent had to provide for you can, in certain circumstances, extend to your surviving step-parent.
The answer is that it can. Courts have recognised that where a surviving spouse has received assets or wealth contributed by their deceased partner, this may give rise to a moral responsibility to consider the deceased partner’s children when making their own testamentary arrangements. This principle has been considered in several important decisions.
Examples from cases
In James v Rost; Lanagan v Rost [2022] VSC 98, the Victorian Supreme Court considered the circumstances in which a testator may have a moral duty to make provision for their stepchildren.
At Paragraph [116] Judge Daly reasoned that:
“The moral duty owed by a testator to step-children in circumstances where their natural parent has been the source of part or all of the assets in the estate has on a number of occasions been recognised as giving rise to a moral duty on the part of a testator.
A further basis for imposing a moral duty upon a testator in favour of step-children is that, in many such cases, the step-children have on the occasion of the death of their natural parent stepped aside in order to protect the resources of the surviving spouse, but need not hold back their claims upon the death of the surviving spouse.
A similar approach was adopted in James v Day [2004] VSC 290:
“it would be wholly inadequate to consider the question of the responsibility of the deceased to make provision for the plaintiffs in isolated concentration upon her circumstances at the immediate time of her death. The question of her responsibility to make provision, in the circumstances of this case, must be approached holistically and historically. When so approached, it is apparent that the genesis of her Estate was the father of the plaintiffs.”
Queensland courts considered a similar case in Freeman v. Jaques [2005] QSC 200
A wise and just stepmother in the deceased’s position whose assets were contributed to some degree by Mr Freeman…would be expected to consider making some provision for at least the children of Mr Freeman who remained in extremely modest and necessitous circumstances, despite benefiting their from father’s estate.
Key takeaways for stepchildren
As community expectations have changed and blended families have become increasingly common, the law of family provision has also developed to recognise the complexities of these relationships. In Rost, the Court observed that:
“the time when step-children in the position of the claimants would be considered to have a far inferior claim to the natural child of a testator has well passed.”
The following points are highly important for stepchildren seeking to challenge an estate:
- Admissible and coherent evidence of the how their biological parent contributed to the wealth ultimately held by the deceased will be critical to a successful claim. This is a holistic inquiry which may require bank statements, property searches, bank accounts or financial statements.
- The fact that biological children may have been closer to the deceased will not necessarily preclude a successful family provision claim; an
- If upon the death of the first parent, the stepchild did not benefit from their estate, this should be taken into account in relation to the second parent’s moral obligation to make adequate provision.
Our recent experience in stepchild cases
We were recently successful in securing 55% of an estate for a stepdaughter who was entirely excluded from her stepmother’s will. Our client’s biological father had contributed to the family properties in the 80’s and his contribution could be traced through to the Deceased’s assets at the time of her death in 2025. The result was secured without the need for litigation or costly court proceedings.
At Rostron Carlyle Lawyers, Michael Sing is experienced in Estate Litigation and would be happy to assist you. Contact us to book a time to discuss.
Disclaimer: The information contained in this blog post is provided for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading or accessing this content does not create a solicitor-client relationship between you and Rostron Carlyle Lawyers. Because stepchild family provision claims depend on the specific facts, family history, and financial evidence of each case, you should not rely on this article as a substitute for tailored legal advice. Please contact Rostron Carlyle Lawyers directly to discuss your individual situation before taking any action.